What Is an Investigative Consumer Report? (And Why a Character Reference Isn’t One)
An investigative consumer report gathers information about someone’s character through personal interviews — and carries extra FCRA rules. Here’s the definition and how it differs from a volunteer character reference.
On this page
“Investigative consumer report” sounds intimidating, and the distinction matters — it’s a specific legal category with its own rules, and it’s often confused with ordinary reference checks.
Investigative consumer report — definition
An investigative consumer report (ICR) is a consumer report in which information about a person’s character, general reputation, or mode of living is obtained through personal interviews with people who know them. Under the FCRA, ICRs carry extra disclosure requirements beyond a standard background check.
How it differs from a standard consumer report
A standard consumer report pulls from records — courts, registries, databases. An investigative one adds a layer: a consumer reporting agency interviews people to develop information about reputation and character. Because that’s more subjective and personal, the FCRA requires additional notice to the person, and gives them the right to learn about the nature and scope of the investigation.
Why a volunteer character reference isn’t an ICR
This is a common and important distinction for nonprofits. When VolunteerBadge collects automated character references, it acts as a neutral conduit: the applicant chooses and authorizes their own references, each reference participates voluntarily and answers in their own words, and VolunteerBadge relays those words to you without investigating, scoring, or verifying them. We do not interview on our own initiative or compile an investigative report about the applicant.
In other words: a character reference collected this way is a personal opinion offered voluntarily — not a consumer report, not an investigative consumer report, and not governed by the FCRA. It’s kept separate from the background check. (Our only role as a CRA is the criminal check on the volunteer themselves.)
Related: What is a consumer report? · How character references work · The full screening glossary
Add verified character references for free. Create a free VolunteerBadge account →
