Skip to content
Statistics

Donor Acquisition Statistics (2026): Retention Gaps, Donor Decline & What Nonprofits Can Do

VolunteerBadge Team·November 17, 2026·8 min read

Donor acquisition statistics for 2026: first-gift retention near 19%, donor counts falling for a fifth straight year, and what nonprofit leaders can do about it.

Screen from $5 per check with a bundle purchase

FCRA-compliant volunteer background checks. No monthly fees.

Nonprofits are raising more money in 2026 but from fewer people. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project, the broadest US tracker of donor behavior, shows dollars rising while donor counts keep slipping, and most first-time givers never make a second gift. This report pulls the latest verified figures on donor retention, giving totals, tax changes, and acquisition economics, and explains what they mean for church, school, and charity leaders. It is part of our statistics hub, and it pairs with our fundraising benchmark report for year-over-year comparisons.

Methodology and honesty note. Every number below comes from a source we located and link directly. Where sources disagree, or where a figure is a secondary compilation rather than a primary release, we say so. We omitted figures we could not verify. Fundraising Effectiveness Project (FEP) figures measure donors who gave to a given organization in one year and gave again the next, and year-to-date (YTD) figures are partial-year estimates that will change. Donor-retention data describes fundraising, not volunteer screening; we apply it to volunteer programs only where the link is direct.

Key takeaways

43.3%overall donor retention for calendar 2025 (FEP)
18.9%first-time donor retention for 2025 (FEP)
11.3%of donors acquired in 2025 who had given again by end of Q2 2026
$592.50Bestimated US charitable giving in 2024 (Giving USA)

The donor pipeline is shrinking even as dollars grow

The FEP's full-year 2025 analysis found that dollars raised rose an estimated 5.0% while donor counts fell an estimated 3.6%, extending a decline that began in 2021. The same report puts the 2025 base at 15,102 organizations, 7.8 million donors and $13.2 billion raised. Growth was concentrated among the largest donors, which means the broad donor base is thinning. Smaller organizations are feeling it most: the FEP's midyear 2025 review noted that the largest organizations saw a 12.2% decline while those under $1 million grew, and the pipeline of new donors was flagged as a concern.

Retention measures the share of donors who give again, so it can hold steady while the overall donor pool shrinks. That is why the three rates below matter more than the headline dollar total.

43.3%
59.3%
18.9%
FEP full-year 2025 retention by donor type. Source: Fundraising Effectiveness Project Q4 2025; Bloomerang glossary (reporting the same figures).

The first gift is the leaky bucket

The clearest acquisition lesson is how sharply retention climbs after a second gift. Bloomerang's donor-retention guide, which draws on FEP data, reports year-to-date retention of 14.4% for one-time donors, 35.2% for two-time donors, 61.8% for donors who gave three to six times, and 90.0% for seven-plus-time donors. Converting the first gift into a second is therefore the single most valuable step in an acquisition program.

One-time donors14.4%
Two-time donors35.2%
Three to six gifts61.8%
Seven-plus gifts90.0%
Year-to-date donor retention by gift frequency. Source: Bloomerang, Donor Retention Guide (citing FEP data).

The first-year problem is not a one-quarter blip. The FEP's 2025 report noted that the number of new donors fell sharply while first-year retention stayed essentially flat. Earlier, NonProfit PRO reported that new donors made up 40% of all donors in the 2024 data, while new donor retention was 19%. For a program that depends on recruiting new supporters, that combination means most acquisition spending has to be repeated each year.

2026 year-to-date: more dollars, fewer retained new donors

The most recent FEP release, covering the second quarter of 2026, shows the same split. Per the NonProfit Times summary, dollars rose 6.6% year to date while donors fell 1.6% and overall retention slipped to 26.4%. New Retained donors fell 9.5%, the steepest decline of any lifecycle stage, and the FEP quarterly report points to the front of the pipeline as where donors are being lost. Because these figures are partial-year, they will be revised; treat them as direction, not final results.

11.3%
51.6%

Year-to-date retention by group compares the three lifecycle rates side by side. The bars below use the Q2 2026 figures reported by Bloomerang from FEP data.

Overall, YTD Q2 202626.4%
Repeat donors, YTD37.5%
New donors, YTD11.3%
Year-to-date retention, Q2 2026. Source: Bloomerang, Donor Retention Guide; FEP quarterly report.

Where the money comes from

Acquisition strategy depends on who is giving. Giving USA estimated that individuals, bequests, foundations and corporations gave an estimated $592.50 billion to US charities in 2024, a 6.3% increase in current dollars and 3.3% after inflation. Individuals remain the core audience. Per the Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy, which prepares the estimates, individual giving was about $392.45 billion in 2024, and religious organizations received the largest share of charitable dollars at 23%.

Individuals66%
Foundations19%
Corporations8%
Bequests8%

Individual giving also reveals a structural tension: its share of the total slipped from 67% in 2023 to 66% in 2024 even as dollars grew. Giving USA's data point is the same one the FEP keeps finding: the money is steady, but the number of people behind it is narrowing.

The 2026 tax change and the household giving base

Tax policy changes who can get a deduction for giving, and therefore the incentive to give at all. The Tax Policy Center estimates that the 90% of households who do not itemize will contribute about 35% of total charitable giving. Beginning in 2026, a new above-the-line deduction lets non-itemizers deduct cash gifts of up to $1,000 for single filers or $2,000 for joint filers. The Conversation projects that 8.7 million more tax filers will donate because of the universal deduction, while the same piece notes a

VolunteerBadge

Ready to stop overpaying for background checks?

Full national criminal checks at $5. Free address history. FCRA compliant from day one. No monthly fees, no contracts.

Create Free Account

Legal Disclaimer: The content on this page is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. VolunteerBadge and ScreenForge Labs, LLC are not law firms and do not provide legal counsel. FCRA requirements and applicable laws vary by jurisdiction and circumstances. For guidance specific to your organization, please consult a qualified attorney.

AI Content Transparency: We use AI tools to assist in the research and drafting of our blog content. That said, the opinions, perspectives, and editorial judgment in every article reflect the author's genuine views and real-world experience. We believe in full transparency about how content is created — because trust matters as much in publishing as it does in background screening.